Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In with Google Sign In with OpenID

Players Marks: Charlton 1-1 Rochdale

For those of you at the Valley tonight your marks please, just copy and paste:

Hamer
Wiggins
Morrison
Taylor
Evina
Pritchard
Hollands
Stephens
Green
Kormorgant
Wright Phillips

Wagstaff n/a
Clarke n/a
Cort n/a

«1

Comments

  • Square pegs in round holes tonight . Players out of position and bad substitutions. Powells had an off night with his decisions but hes been fantastic all season so we can't be too harsh but it's no goal in open play since Jan 2nd and that's a worry.
    Fans that booed at the end don't deserve a winning team. Disgracefull .


    Hamer - 6
    Wiggins - 5
    Morrison - 6
    Taylor - 6
    Evina - 5
    Pritchard - 5.5
    Hollands - 6.5
    Stephens - 6
    Green - 5.5
    Kormorgant 7.5 Man of the match .
    Wright Phillips - 5.5

    Wagstaff - 4
    Clarke - 3
    Powell - 3
  • Hamer 6.5
    Wiggins 5.5
    Morrison 6
    Taylor 6
    Evina 5.5
    Pritchard 6
    Hollands 6.5
    Stephens 5.5
    Green 6.5
    Kermorgant 8 MOTM
    Wright Phillips 6
  • Hamer 5
    Wiggins 5
    Morrison 5
    Taylor 6
    Evina 5
    Pritchard 4
    Hollands 7
    Stephens 5
    Green 5
    Kormorgant 8.5 MOTM - As usual
    Wright Phillips 6

  • Hamer 7
    Wiggins 6
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7
    Evina 5
    Pritchard 5
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 5
    Green 5
    Kormorgant 7
    Wright Phillips 6

    Wagstaff n/a
    Clarke n/a
    Cort n/a

    It was a game where the manager got it wrong.

    That aside the passing was so slow, the midfield needs a HUGE kick up the arris.
  • Hamer 6.5 looking confident.
    Wiggins 5 didn't realise how left footed he is. Did not work at rb
    Morrison 6.5
    Taylor. 6.5
    Evina 5 could do with a few games behind him
    Pritchard. 5.5 Ineffective
    Hollands.6.5
    Stephens 6 still a bit rusty
    Green. 6, would of kept him on personally, big lumps up front with no one to cross the ball=no sense
    Kermorgant 8 mom.
    Wright Phillips 6
  • Sorry but how anyone can score evina or pritchard above three watched a different game.
  • Hamer 7 Improving
    Wiggins 5 out of position and should have been changed earlier
    Morrison 6
    Taylor 6
    Evina 4 poor
    Pritchard 4 poor
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 5 poor
    Green 6 why did he go off?
    Kormorgant 7.5 MOM
    Wright Phillips 6
  • Hamer 6
    Wiggins 5 out of position
    Morrison 6
    Taylor 6
    Evina 5 poor
    Pritchard 4 out of position and poor
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 6
    Green 6
    Kermorgant 7.5 good goal and MOM
    Wright Phillips 7
  • Hamer 6 good distribution
    Wiggins 5 not a rb
    Morrison 6 gave 100%
    Taylor 6 looked comfortable except the goal
    Evina 5 could do with more games as he wasnt up to speed decision wise
    Pritchard 4 looked so small out there
    Hollands 5 usual game
    Stephens 4 looked slow
    Green 6 dangerous but still lacking that killer ball
    Kormorgant 7.5 what a game he had and a fk to rival king jj
    Wright Phillips 7 looked dangerous today but ref seemed to be against him unlucky.

    I would like to note that rochdale looked up for it today and in my opinion their bald midfielder was mom he was everywhere.
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Taylor - 6
    Evina - 4
    Pritchard - 4.5
    Hollands - 6
    Stephens - 5
    Green - 6.5
    Kormorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips - 7

    Wagstaff n/a
    Clarke n/a
    Cort n/a
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 6.5
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7
    Evina - 6
    Pritchard - 5.5
    Hollands - 6.5
    Stephens 7
    Green 7
    Kormorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips 7
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 5 Square peg round hole
    Morrison - 6
    Taylor - 6
    Evina - 5 At fault with goal.
    Pritchard - 5 Square peg round hole
    Hollands - 6.5
    Stephens - 6
    Green - 5.5 Square peg round hole
    Kormorgant 8
    Wright Phillips - 6


  • Hamer-6
    Wiggins-4-(not his fault)
    Morrison-6
    Taylor-6
    Evina-4
    Pritchard-4
    Hollands-5
    Stephens-5
    Green-6
    Kormorgant-7
    Wright Phillips-6

    Wagstaff n/a
    Clarke n/a
    Cort n/
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 6
    Morrison - 7.5
    Taylor - 7
    Evina - 5.5
    Pritchard - 5.5
    Hollands - 6
    Stephens - 6
    Green - 5.5
    Kormorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips - 6.5
  • Hamer 6
    Wiggins 6
    Morrison 6.5 extra half mark for being our most productive winger in the last ten mins
    Taylor 6
    Evina 4
    Pritchard 5
    Hollands 5
    Stephens 5
    Green 5
    Kormorgant 8
    Wright Phillips 5
  • Hamer - 6.5 Did what he had to no chance with the goal
    Wiggins - 6 Did his best out of position great tackle at the end to prevent a goal
    Morrison - 7 Led by example
    Taylor - 6.5 Tidy just gets on with it.
    Evina - 4 Poor display, nearly gave a goal away 1st half and managed to achieve it 2nd half
    Pritchard - 4.5 Out of position, out of touch and out of his depth tonight legs had gone but never hid.
    Hollands - 6 Kept at it another who just got on with it
    Stephens - 5 Tried to get things going to little effect wasted a lot of possession
    Green - 5 Out of position and Just not doing it for me
    Kormorgant - 8 Where would we be without him, great goal never stops trying
    Wright Phillips - 7 Best game for ages why oh why was he subbed??????

    Wagstaff n/a - 5 After calling for him to come on to shake it up he wasn't noticed!
    Clarke n/a - 6 Looked better than his last cameo appearance
    Cort n/a - 6 Shouldve have been on at half time Morro to RB, Evina subbed and Pritchard subbed for Waggy
    Management - 5 Lost the plot tonight please, please, please, give yourself more options from the bench and don't play people out of position!
  • Hamer 6.5 Nothing to do. Not at fault for the goal.
    Wiggins 5 Poor
    Morrison 7 CBs were tidy.
    Taylor 7.5 ditto MOM
    Evina 4.5 Not match fit. Has potential, the lad is only 20!
    Pritchard 7 Not everything went well for him but he was tidy out of position and he was everywhere! Don't understand some of these results.
    Hollands 6.5 Done the jobs nobody else wanted to do.
    Stephens 5 Lost his magic since being injured.
    Green 5.5 Not a lot wrong but very ineffective. Better than Waggy though.
    Kormorgant 7.5 extra .5 for the goal. He was a leader tonight.
    Wright Phillips 7 A confident BWP would've scored his chances tonight. Looked up for it.

  • Hamer 6.5 - Nothing much to do; goal not his fault
    Wiggins 6.0 - Did what he could out of position
    Morrison 7.0 - Reliable as ever
    Taylor 6.5 - Solid
    Evina 5.0 - Sorry fo the guy; wrong match; wrong circumstances to give him a chance
    Pritchard 5.5 - Out of position; showed his inexperience
    Hollands 6.0 - Poor; showed their mid-field too much respect
    Stephens 6,0 - Same as Hollands
    Green 6.0 - Out of position; didn't allow for Evina's inexperience
    Kormorgant- 7.5 Great goal; tireless performance
    Wright Phillips - 7.0 Worked hard; needs better service

    Wagstaff - showed why Green gets picked to start ahead of him; not the player he was last season
    Clarke - still not convinced he brings anything to the attack; no pace or agility
    Cort n/a
    CP lost the plot tonight; a chance to get it sorted for Saturday. COYR's
  • Hamer - 6 Solid, nothing much to do.
    Wiggins - 6 Played out of position and did him no favours.
    Morrison - 7 Solid defending again.
    Taylor - 7 Gave Waggy a bollocking to man up ( or something like that ). Decent captain and no thrills defending.
    Evina - 7 Did OK as cover for Wiggins.
    Pritchard - 6 Tough little midfielder.
    Hollands - 6 Battled well in midfield.
    Stephens - 6 Ditto. Unlucky not to score yet another rocket from 25 yards out.
    Green - 5 Frustrating again but playing out of position did not help. Lacked urgency, woeful crossing and set pieces.
    Kormorgant - 8 MOM. Great free kick for equaliser, hassled defenders & won the ball back in midfield.
    Wright Phillips - 6 Unlucky with a couple of shots and off balance with a couple more chances.

    Waggy - Please keep your arms down, play to the whistle and stop moaning ffs! Not good enough.
    Clarke - Can see him starting on saturday to beef up the front line.
    Cort - Solid.
  • Hamer 6
    Wiggins 5
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 6.5
    Evina 4
    Pritchard 5
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 5
    Green 6
    Kormorgant 8
    Wright Phillips 6
  • Hamer 6 - little to do
    Wiggins 6 - wasted for 82 minutes
    Morrison - 6 little to do
    Taylor -6 little to do
    Evina- 4 started ok, but began to make errors and didn't recover.
    Pritchard - 3 totally ineffective in either wide position, kept wandering inside leaving the right hand side without any threat.
    Hollands - 6 won and used the ball well, but it brokedown elsewhere
    Stephens - 6 won and used the ball ok, couple of odd decisions, maybe trying too hard without any natural width.
    Green - 6 looked lost out left, only saw worthwhile ball from him when he came right. Looked to be getting going on the right but then substituted................. odd.
    Kermorgant - 7.5 dread to think what may of happened without him tonight.
    Wright Phillips - 6

    Rochdale were so poor, that is what frustrated me the most, they were there for the taking.
    Our management would score the lowest tonight, left me scratching my head, before during and after the game.
  • Hamer - 6.5
    Wiggins - 6
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7
    Evina - 5.5
    Pritchard - 6
    Hollands - 6.5
    Stephens - 6.5
    Green - 6
    Kermorgant - 9
    Wright Phillips - 6
  • Hamer 6
    Wiggins 4 - he used his right foot once in the first half, and it created our first chance. shame that was the only time it came out. Not his fault he was out of position but apart from the last 10 mins he didn't offer much.
    Morrison 6
    Taylor 6
    Evina 4
    Pritchard 4
    Hollands 5 two foot too far away from every ball in the midfield
    Stephens 5 ditto - seemed to gain some clumsy feet
    Green 4
    Kormorgant 7 great game.
    Wright Phillips 6
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 7 Tried his best , but not suited to that position
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7
    Evina - 4 Really Really rusty , mixture of some good , some bad , gave away the ball to set up their goal
    Pritchard - 6
    Hollands - 6
    Stephens - 6 Gave the ball away too much , but had some good passes
    Green - 6.5 Out of position , tried his best
    Kermorgant - 8 Quality free kick , good to see him on the score sheet.
    Wright Phillips - 7 Few chances , the goal will come , now Kermo's got one

    Wagstaff n/a - Very disappointing cameo
    Clarke n/a - Did alright
    Cort n/a
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 5 (Totally not his fault as was played way out of position)
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7
    Evina - 5
    Pritchard - 5
    Hollands - 6
    Stephens - 3 (An absolutely shambolic performance)
    Green - 6
    Kormorgant - 8.5 (Fantastic as always)
    Wright Phillips - 5 (Ever seen so many air kicks?)
  • Hamer 6.5
    Wiggins 6
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7
    Evina 5
    Pritchard 5.5
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 5.5
    Green 6
    Kermorgant 7.5
    Wright Phillips 6.5
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 6 sad to see one of our best attacking options played out of position, you wouldn't play gareth bale right back
    Morrison - 6
    Taylor - 6
    Evina - 5
    Pritchard - 5 not sure what position he was playing
    Hollands - 6
    Stephens - 7
    Green - 6 played out of position
    Kormorgant - 8 mom
    Wright Phillips - 6
  • Hamer 6
    Wiggins 6
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7
    Evina 5.5
    Pritchard 5.5
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 6
    Green 6
    Kermorgant 7.5
    Wright Phillips 6

    Wagstaff n/a Now i know why he is not getting a game
    Clarke n/a
    Cort n/a
  • Hamer 6 made two good saves.
    Wiggins 5 He is not a right back so not his fault he sruggled.
    Morrison 6
    Taylor 6
    Evina 6
    Pritchard 6
    Hollands 5
    Stephens 4 poor display
    Green 5
    Kormorgant 7
    Wright Phillips 5 as he muffed two chances to hit the target.
  • Hamer 7
    Wiggins 6 not a right back
    Morrison 7 looked quite good is his RB cameo
    Taylor 6.5
    Evina 5 rusty,
    Pritchard 5 tried hard but not a good game
    Hollands 6 anonymous
    Stephens 5 slow, not enough attacking threat, not enough defensive cover
    Green 6 much better on the right
    Kormorgant 7 our best player
    Wright Phillips 6 played well but missed 2 possible chances

    Wagstaff 4 poor cameo, did nothing to further his cause
    Clarke 6 did OK dealing with hit and hope service
    Cort 6

    SCP 3 strange 1st 11 and bench, odd substitutions

    I thought Rochdale played well, they knocked it around quite nicely and I hope they stay up
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 5
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 6
    Evina - 3
    Pritchard - 3
    Hollands - 6.5
    Stephens - 4.5
    Green - 4.5
    Kormorgant - 8 MOTM (Absolute class)
    Wright Phillips - 7

    Beginning to panic about Sheff Utd now.
  • Hamer - 7 Always found Yann's head with the ball. Looked absolutely furious at the end
    Wiggins - 5.5 Seems to hate his righht foot. Can't be blamed but the performance was poor
    Morrison - 7 Imperious at the back
    Taylor - 6 Some dodgy distribution today
    Evina - 5 Looked terrified, seemed to charge straight into players rather than take them on and caught out for the goal
    Pritchard - 5 Frustrating on the ball and weaker in the tackle than we're used to seeing. Disappointing
    Hollands - 6 When he gets his foot on the ball he's a wonderful passer but spent too much time with soft headers
    Stephens - 4 Nowhere to be seen. Sat too deep to be effective but didn't track their runners when needed, giving us the worst of both worlds
    Green - 6 Uncomfortable on the left, offered something down the right before being replaced
    Kermorgant - 7.5 Rochdale must be glad we only had one of him. Great player
    Wright Phillips - 6.5 Sharp and nimble and unfortunate to be subbed

    Wagstaff n/a
    Clarke n/a
    Cort n/a
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 5.5
    Morrison - 7.5
    Taylor - 6.5
    Evina - 5
    Pritchard - 4.5
    Hollands - 5
    Stephens - 5.5
    Green - 6.5
    Kormorgant - 9 Outstanding
    Wright Phillips - 7


  • Hamer - 6
    Wiggins - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Taylor - 6
    Evina - 6
    Pritchard - 6
    Hollands - 6
    Stephens - 6
    Green - 6
    Kermorgant - 8
    Wright Phillips - 7

    Wagstaff n/a
    Clarke n/a - 1
    Cort n/a
  • last_line said:

    Sorry but how anyone can score evina or pritchard above three watched a different game.

    That's all of us then ! It's not there fault that CP cocked up tonight

  • Hamer 6 did what he had to do no chance with the goal

    Wiggins 6 not a right back

    Morrison 7 solid and a better right back than Wiggins not that that says much!

    Taylor 6.5 usual solid but unspectacular performance

    Evina 5.5 Sorry to mark a player making his full league debut below par but at fault for Rochdale's goal so no option

    Pritchard 6 I've liked him but he looked ordinary and lightweight tonight possibly because he is not a winger

    Hollands 7 decent first half not so effective in the second

    Stephens 6 8 when he joined in 4 when he went AWOL average 6

    Green 6 Frustrating!!!!!!!

    Kormorgant 8 MOM by a street both in the air and on the ground and a quality free kick for the goal too

    Wright Phillips 6.5 worked hard but it isn't happening for him at the moment

    Wagstaff n/a 6 anonymous for a supposed impact sub and did not make himself available and cover the ground in his usual fashion. Friction in the ranks or lacking sharpness through little football but something aint right

    Clarke n/a 6 Best I've seen from him which says very little!

    Cort n/a 6
  • hamer .6 same ol same wiggy .5 out o position. Morro .6 Taylor. 6 eEvina Poo 5.. ..Pritch..Poo Poo...3 H..ollands 5..sluggish Stephens, Poor 5 ..Green 5.wrong side .Kermie .8 class apart...Bwp 6.5 worked hard..Waggie..3..moaner..
  • Hamer-6
    Wiggins-6.5
    Morrison-7
    Taylor-6.5
    Evina-5
    Pritchard-6
    Hollands-6
    Stephens-6
    Green-6
    Kormorgant-8
    Wright Phillips-6.5

    Wagstaff - 5 He didn't actually do anything apart from complain, blew his chance to make an impact
    Clarke -5 Was it a really bad miss at the end??? Still don't know why we signed him
  • Hamer - 6
    Wiggins - 5
    Morrison - 6
    Taylor - 6
    Evina - 5.5
    Pritchard - 5
    Hollands - 5.5
    Stephens - 5
    Green - 5.5
    Kormorgant 7
    Wright Phillips 6
  • I will mark tomorrow, but I will be giving Pritchard an extra 2 marks just to spite all the above who who obviously want to pin our bad performance on him.
    Total bollox.
  • Hamer 7
    Wiggins 4
    Morrison 7.5
    Taylor 7
    Evina 4
    Pritchard 4
    Hollands 6.5
    Stephens 4
    Green 6
    Kormorgant 8.5
    Wright Phillips 6.5
  • last_line said:

    Sorry but how anyone can score evina or pritchard above three watched a different game.

    YES!
  • I will mark tomorrow, but I will be giving Pritchard an extra 2 marks just to spite all the above who who obviously want to pin our bad performance on him.
    Total bollox.

    Agreed, play him in his proper position and there's not a chance he'd let you down as much as Stephens did tonight.

    Hamer - 6. Did nothing wrong but distribution slow at times.
    Wiggins - 5.5. Far less effective on the right, looked uncomfortable.
    Morrison - 6.5. Solid game, ever-reliable.
    Taylor - 6.5. As above. Unsure where the rumblings of discontent in recent weeks regarding Taylor have emerged from.
    Evina - 5. Nervous opening, grew into the game but unquestionably at fault for their goal.
    Pritchard - 6. Not his best game - or position for that matter - but his endeavour sits well with me when things aren't going to plan.
    Hollands - 7. Calming influence, one of a few who could exit the field satisfied with their showing.
    Stephens - 5.5. Sloppy, caught dithering on the ball too often. Seems to lack the awareness he showed pre-injury.
    Green - 5.5. Deployed on the left initially but looked more threatening after half-time.
    Kermorgant - 8.5. Terrific workhorse and stunning goal to boot;
    Wright Phillips - 6.5. Anticipates Yann's flicks more often than not but caught marginally offside at least three times. The goal will come soon.

  • Hamer - 6
    Wiggins - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Taylor - 6
    Evina - 5
    Pritchard - 8.5
    Hollands - 6.5
    Stephens - 5
    Green - 6
    Kermorgant - 9
    Wright Phillips - 6
  • Hamer 6
    Wiggins 6
    Evina 6
    Taylor 6.5
    Morrison 6.5
    Pritchard 6
    Hollands 6
    Stephens 6
    Green 6
    BWP 6.5
    Kermogrant 7.5
  • Hamer 6.5 Not much to do and no chance with wicked deflection for goal
    Wiggins 5 Good point earlier about not realising how left footed he is - a major error playing himn at RB in this game- would have been understandable against stronger opponents but we needed his attacking flair in this game.
    Morrison 7 Thought he was excellent and supported the attack well.
    Taylor. 6.5 Solid
    Evina 5 Some good stuff offensively but not consistently and an not the best defensively.
    Pritchard. 5 Nearly scored but not his best game.
    Hollands. 7 decent game
    Stephens 6.5 done ok
    Green. 6, Needs to play on right - would have kept him on with Waggy as a makeshift attacking RB and had Wiggins and Evina (with Wiggins as LB on the left.
    Kermorgant 8 mom. Wins so many headers, won th efreekick and what a free kick
    Wright Phillips 6 looked sharp but missing that spark
  • Hamer 7
    Wiggins 5
    Evina 6
    Taylor 7
    Morrison 7
    Pritchard 4
    Hollands 7
    Stephens 6
    Green 7
    BWP 7
    Kermogant 7.5
  • I know some were played out of position but my marks reflect their actual performance.

    Hamer - 6.5. No chance with the goal but other than that had little to do.
    Wiggins - 5. Looked all at sea and restricted play by coming inside. No attacking threat even when he switched late on
    Morrison - 7. We looked far more balanced when Morro went to RB and he gave us some attacking options which we had lacked.
    Taylor - 7. Steady and reliable in the middle.
    Evina - 5. One good foray in the first half but Dale got behind him too often. He wasn't helped by having Green ahead of him so this may have affected his performance.
    Pritchard - 5. Not a winger. Very little end product
    Hollands - 7.5. Sterling performance. With weaknesses on either side of him he had to do the work of others but still shone
    Stephens - 5. For the 'creative' midfielder he creates precious little and slows the play with his back and square passing. His tackling is non-existent too.
    Green - 5. Out of position but still was poor. No effort to take on his full back because he knew he had to come back onto his right foot.
    Kermorgant - 8. Another all-round action performanceand superb strike. His tackling back to regain the ball is an added bonus (Stephens take note!!)
    Wright Phillips - 7. He is working very hard and created problems for Dale's defence. Seemed to be on the same wavelength as Yann last night
    Wagstaff - 4.5. As he had 30 minutes I think he justified being marked. Unfortunately he made absolutely no impact. His first involvement was to fall over and claim a foul - one of a number rightly ignored by the ref.
  • Hamer 7 - decent handling and distribution, no chance with the goal
    Wiggins 6 - struggled out of position
    Morrison 7 - another reliable performance
    Taylor 7.5 - really impressed with how he captains the side, very vocal, and another good showing
    Evina 6 - needs games, but did ok.
    Pritchard 7 - gets an extra half mark for his work rate, but he's more effective inside
    Hollands 7 - spent most of his time making up for Stephens giving the ball away
    Stephens 5.5 - poor
    Green 5 - poorer
    Kormorgant 8 - motm, yes he wins headers but he works tirelessly - did more work in midfield than Green and Stephens put together, and he was playing up front. Great goal
    Wright Phillips 7 - not convinced he should have been taken off when he was, good movement, ball just not running for him.
  • Hamer - 7
    Wiggins - 5
    Morrison - 6.5
    Taylor - 6.5
    Evina - 5.5
    Pritchard - 5
    Hollands - 6.5
    Stephens - 4.5
    Green - 4
    Kermorgant - 7
    Wright Phillips - 6

    Wagstaff n/a
    Clarke n/a
    Cort n/a


Sign In or Register to comment.